Digital audio cable types
As an alternative to analogue cables as the interconnect between source components and amplification, digital cables are used in some systems. These have the advantage of being resistant to interference and should deliver excellent results, as long as the digital-to-analogue conversion in the amplification is at least as good as that in the source component. Indeed, some CD and network players are designed as transport-only devices with no onboard digital-to-analogue conversion. These devices are intended to be connected to digital inputs on the amplifier or preamplifier.
There are two main kinds of digital cable – electrical (essentially a specialised version of the same connection used for analogue hook-ups) and optical. In both cases, a single connection is needed to carry both audio channels or even multiple channels in a surround setup.
Electrical digital cables
Essentially, carrying the digital datastream over a twin-conductor cable, like that used for a single analogue audio channel, is often generalised as a ‘coaxial digital’ cable, though a variety of connectors and cable configurations are used. Common configurations are RCA phono plug connectors, BNC connectors and XLR-plugged AES/EBU connectors, which use a balanced cable construction.
The important consideration here is that a cable designed for digital should be used for digital signals: cables designed for analogue audio will work but aren’t ideal. It’s all a matter of cable impedance (or to simplify, resistance): the standard for a coaxial digital connection using RCA plugs is a 75 ohm impedance (coincidentally, once familiar for connecting FM radio antennae). For AES/EBU connections, it’s 110 ohm.
As both coaxial and optical digital connections conform to the Sony/Philips Digital interface (S/PDIF), which combines both the signal and timing information in a single datastream, there is the potential for mistiming in the transmission. This leads to what’s called ‘jitter’ and occurs when the receiving device loses track of the timing signal. The device must then work hard to recover a coherent datastream on which the digital-to-analogue conversion can work.
A major cause of this is incorrect impedance in the digital cables, which can cause the signal to reflect within the cable, messing up the accurate transmission of the high-speed digital signals.
To further combat this, some proprietary systems have been developed that carry the clock signal and data on separate cables. There’s also the I2S (or Inter-Integrated Circuit Sound) connection, which replicates the way data is transmitted within digital components using a separate clock line as well as those for the left and right channels. It also features a ‘word select line’ to tell the receiver which channel each bit it’s receiving describes.
The problem is there’s no standard for an I2S connector. Some recent components use a multipin HDMI-type connector, but the connection doesn’t conform to the HDMI standard and there can even be variance between hardware manufacturers when it comes to ‘which pin does what’.
Optical digital ‘cables’
In theory, optical digital connections should be superior to those with metal-based cables. After all, optical is immune to interference. Optical ‘cables’ (they’re actually fibre-optic light-pipes) are also used for high-speed data transfer, so they must be better, right?
Most optical cables you’ll encounter will use the inexpensive TOSLINK connector, so called because it was developed by Toshiba. This connector type is fixed on the end of a light-pipe formed by a single strand of glass or plastic (or bundle of such fibres), covered by a protective jacket. How well that assembly is put together determines how well it performs. Prices range from almost nothing for a thin plastic cable all the way up to ‘high-end’ money for a glass core terminated in exotic versions of the TOSLINK connector. Some companies even make gold-plated TOSLINK connectors.
Yes, optical connections have a theoretical advantage in their immunity to electrical interference, but there’s a lot of potential for error resulting from reflections within the optical fibre. This is especially true where it’s joined to the connector and where the plug connects with the port on the devices you’re connecting.
There’s one more consideration: it’s easy to think that optical is good because, after all, CD is an optical medium read using a laser. However, the player converts those optical pulses into an electrical signal, so connecting a player to the digital input on an amplifier or DAC means the data goes optical-electrical-optical-electrical, which can introduce even more errors.